Tuesday 3 June 2014

The Kingdom of Childhood by Rebecca Coleman


Judy McFarland is a kindergarten teacher in a Steiner school, who feels trapped in a loveless marriage and a job that has become routine.  When high school student Zach Patterson is assigned to help her prepare for an upcoming school fundraiser, Judy starts a risky sexual relationship with him.  Initially Zach is thrilled at the attention, as it diverts his mind from his mother's affair and the subsequent effect on his family, but gradually the relationship between Zach and Judy changes and becomes darker, as Judy comes to term with the secrets of her past.

I do like a novel about a controversial subject, so I was keen to pick up The Kingdom of Childhood. Sexual predators in novels tend to be men, so I was interested to see how Coleman would deal with the abuser being female.  And actually I thought this was well done - although Zach is flattered initially with Judy's attention, by the middle of the novel he has had enough and would like to be free of her.  This is where the power dynamic comes into play, as Judy manipulates him into continuing to have sex with her, with both parties acknowledging that the 'relationship' is actually rape. I liked that Coleman portrayed this honestly, rather than taking the easier 'surely it's every male's fantasy to get with a hot teacher' road, that I've seen before when female teachers have been caught abusing their pupils.  

However, I wasn't a fan of the sub-plot about Judy's past.  Every couple of chapters, there is a flashback about Judy's experiences growing up in Bavaria, where she witnessed her father's extra-marital affair and was groomed herself, alongside other secrets.  I liked the atmosphere of these parts of the novel, but there was so much build up that the 'shocking secrets' when they came didn't feel so shocking after all.  It's like Coleman was trying to make this book as controversial as possible by adding this sub-plot when she didn't really need to, as surely the main plot is controversial enough.  The added elements seemed to cheapen it somehow.

Although The Kingdom of Childhood was thought provoking and well written, I think my experience of reading it suffered as I couldn't help but compare it to Alissa Nutting's Tampa, also about a female teacher abusing a student.  Tampa is far from an enjoyable read, but it's confronting, powerful and shocking, and deals with this issue in a much more successful way than The Kingdom of Childhood.  Readers that haven't read Tampa will probably find it more thought-provoking than I did.

Source: Personal copy (kindle)
First Published: 2012
Score: 3 out of 5

11 comments:

  1. I haven't read Tampa yet but it's on my list. Looks like this had good ideas and initial direction but went in for sensation rather than subtle storytelling.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't mind sensation (Tampa has lots of it), but I felt like this book didn't really shine a light on the issues as much as it could have done.

      Delete
  2. As soon as you mentioned what it was about I thought TAMPA. Notably, Coleman's book came out first and is set in Britain. I wonder if that changes anything.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Coleman's book is set in America - you might be thinking of Notes on a Scandal?

      Delete
  3. I hadn't heard too much about Tampa before, but it's always interesting to look at two books side-by-side that deal with the same subject -- especially when that subject is controversial. Good to know which from among the choices addresses the issue more successfully. There is definitely a double-standard when it comes thing kind of thing and I think that kind of thing makes for thought-provoking reading.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, Tampa is the more worthwhile read even though it's not easy to read. I have a pretty high tolerance but I found it difficult to get through.

      Delete
  4. It's a such a draw-you-in kind of title...too bad it's not the kind of story I like to read. Great post, though.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think that it's a good idea to include view points and subjects like these in books, and that even though you didn't really love it, you got something out of it! Now I am looking up Tampa!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Tampa is worth reading, although it's not an easy read at all. It's also based on a true life case.

      Delete
  6. Oh poo. It's too bad when a book builds something up forever only to have the result fizzle out.

    Whew, Tampa. That book made me absolutely speechless.

    ReplyDelete