Tom Sawyer and I have history. Way back when I was eleven, we read parts of this book as a class during our English lessons. The problem with this was that my English teacher at the time was the most uncharismatic person you can imagine and had a gift for making things boring. He also loved accents and when I say loved, I mean loved. He would randomly pick people from the class to read aloud and then force them to put on a Southern accent (I am British). At the age of eleven I was very shy and consequently spent every lesson anxious that I would have to do the accent in front of everyone else and they would all laugh at me. Unsurprisingly, I learned nothing about the book and came to dislike it strongly!
A few weeks ago, I decided the time had come to see whether this horrible teaching led to me missing out on a great book or whether the book really was just boring after all. Telling episodes in the childhood of Tom Sawyer, a cheeky rapscallion living in Illinois in the 1800s, The Adventures of Tom Sawyer is a chronicle of the kind of childhood not many people experience anymore, one filled with outdoor adventure, exploration, brushes with danger, tricks and imagination. It also offers a vivid portrait of the South at that time, especially the Mississippi river.
Thankfully, it was only poor teaching putting me off a great book as I thoroughly enjoyed Tom Sawyer. It grabbed my attention from the moment I picked it up and transported me to the rural South. Each time I had to put the book down, I had to remind myself that I was in England in 2012 and not on the banks of the Mississippi. Tom endeared himself to me immediately; he's a lovable rogue who gets into lots of scrapes and does lots of bad things, but you never doubt that his heart is in the right place. Twain does a remarkable job at capturing the wonder of childhood with all its imagination and emotion.
The Adventures of Tom Sawyer is a romantic book, not because it contains romance, but because it presents an idyllic picture of rural childhood where children are free to roam and play until their hearts' content. Although there is danger (Injun Joe!), it never feels real or as if it will threaten the bubble of childhood. As a teacher it made me reflect on how different childhood is now and how sad it is that many children now don't play Robin Hood or cowboys and Indians, don't use their imaginations in the way Tom and his friends did. They don't explore their surroundings and aren't given the freedom they once were. I remember trekking along a muddy river bank and climbing trees when I was younger, but how many children do that now?
Although Tom was an engaging character, the character that really interested me was Huckleberry Finn. Tom is a 'safe' character to write about as he has family that loves him and a decent education, however much he gets into scrapes he will grow out of it and turn out OK. Huck on the other hand has none of the opportunities Tom has, deserted by an alcoholic father and living on the fringes of society. Tom thinks this is all very glamorous and exciting, but Huck himself is aware of how lucky Tom is. It made me want to read Huckleberry Finn soon, I have a feeling it might be better than Tom Sawyer.
I enjoyed the initial sections of the book the most (loved the chapter where Toms tricks his friends into doing painting the fence for him) but thought that parts of the story surrounding Injun Joe and the treasure were a bit silly. Injun Joe was a good 'bad guy' but Twain was treading a fine line between the believable and the unbelievable. For this reason, it wasn't a 5 star read for me, but one that I enjoyed very much. I can't believe what I was missing out on for all these years!
Source: Library
First Published: 1876
Score: 4 out of 5
When you wrote that Tom was a "cheeky rapscallion," I thought that was one of the best and funniest descriptions I've ever heard. I taught this book to my sister a few years ago (she was homeschooled at the time), and I think that Injun Joe and his treasure has to be seen through that lens of childhood magic too. Perhaps Tom's recounting is not exactly the way things happened.
ReplyDeleteI'm glad you enjoyed this one!
I love the word rapscallion, I was just glad of a chance to use it! How wonderful that you got to teach your sister a bit, that's not something everyone gets the chance to do. Maybe Injun Joe was just a bit much for my jaded adult eyes!
DeleteIt's astounding to me how much effect bad teaching actually can have on students (of any age)...I hated poetry until graduate school...I probably will never love it, but I was finally given the opportunity to truly appreciate it only after being forced to memorize and recite the classics over and over and over and over again...I enjoy Tom Sawyer read aloud...but I'm from Mississippi and I can soooo do that accent :)
ReplyDeleteUnfortunately, bad teaching lasts longer than good teaching. Luckily I had an excellent English Lit teacher for my later years in secondary school and I got a love of Shakespeare and poetry from her. I imagine Tom Sawyer is lovely read aloud in your accent but it's definitely not in mine! :P
DeleteTeachers have a lot to answer for sometimes; both good and bad! Not a book I have ever read, but then I have vague recollections of a television series about Huckleberry Finn? or have I just dreamt that one up? Perhaps I should read the book.
ReplyDeleteLiking the new blog look as well. Hope you are enjoying the Easter break
Jo, although I hadn't read the whole book parts of it were very familiar -I think it might have entered our minds via cultural osmosis. I'm excited to read Huck Finn soon.
DeleteAnd the Easter break has been lovely! Too bad I have to go back to work next week...
I don't think I've read this book since I was ten years old, but it was one of my favorites growing up. I wanted to be just like Tom and Huck. I have clearer memories of Huckleberry Finn, but I'm sure you'll love it.
ReplyDeleteI really need to reread these Twain classics sometime soon.
I wish I had been introduced to it better at age eleven, I think if left to my own devices I would really have loved it. I can't wait to read Huck Finn now!
DeleteHe would randomly pick people from the class to read aloud and then force them to put on a Southern accent (I am British).
ReplyDeleteThis made me cringe...
I don't remember much of either book, and ought to revisit them at some point, but I do think The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn is a darker book. There's light-heartedness in it too, but his companion in the book is a slave, Jim, who's in danger of being sold down the river. There's slavery, racism, bloodshed... I'll be interested in reading your take on it.
It was awful, even the more confident kids hated it, let alone the shy ones like me. I do want to read Huck Finn, and think it's good that it is a bit darker. Hopefully I'll get to it within the next few months.
DeleteI read this so long ago I have forgotten it. It was nice to read your review and recall it. I really need to re-read Tom Sawyer soon.
ReplyDeletei love your review of this book. i hate this book, however. er...i dislike this book. could be because i live in missouri and find it all boring. thanks for showing this book in such a wonderful light that i feel compelled to dust off my old copy. :D
ReplyDelete