Dreams of Joy is the sequel to Shanghai Girls, which I read and loved back in August. Those of you who have read Shanghai Girls will remember that Joy had just found out that her mother Pearl isn't really her mother at all but her aunt, and that her biological father is an artist still living in China. With the impulsiveness and surety of youth, Joy gives up her American life and travels to Communist China to 'help build the New China'. Looking at everything through rose-tinted glasses, she thinks she has found a rural idyll and a simple life far away from the consumerism and prejudice she has experienced in America. So she thinks nothing of surrendering her passport, of losing her ability to travel around China, of falling in love with a man from the village (now Dandelion Commune number eight). Pearl, with the wisdom of experience, can see the trouble her daughter is involving herself with and also abandons everything to travel to China in an attempt to bring her home.
I was apprehensive about reading Dreams of Joy, as I enjoyed Shanghai Girls so much, but I shouldn't have worried - I loved it. Throughout the whole first half of the book, as Joy embraced Communist China and commune life and all it stood for I wanted to reach through the book and shake her. Having studied The Great Leap Forward and Communist China, I had a great sense of foreboding and was waiting for the other shoe to drop. Joy is so headstrong and so determined to love everything about China and village life that she is beyond being made to see otherwise, and at a certain point, Pearl has to let her make her own mistakes. Other reviewers have complained of Joy's naivety for thinking everything is charming and perfect in the communes, but I thought it fit with her character - when you are so determined for something to be right, you simply don't see the bad.
In the second half of the book, the other shoe drops as See starts describing the effects of The Great Leap Forward. Communes were led by leaders that had no clue about farming, leading to mistakes in planting and harvesting and consequently a radical drop in food production. At the same time, the pressure was on to have higher and higher yields leading to a massive famine, with some estimates putting it at 45 million dead. People started to abandon and even eat their own babies and children out of desperation. I thought See effectively conveyed the suffering of people that had been made to abandon the farming practises that they knew worked, for those that they knew wouldn't, but were unable to speak up due to terrible consequences for those that did. Starving must be truly a terrible way to die. Other aspects of Communist China are touched upon - meetings where 'rightist elements' are denounced, internal travel restrictions, cruelty towards anyone who had been well off before communism, unrealistic targets and announcements. As always, See had done her research and wrote about these topics knowledgeably.
Some parts of the plot did require a bit of suspension of belief in the way that the characters were able to move around the country and make plans to leave whilst remaining undetected. I also missed the character of May, who stayed in America and was only in the novel in the form of letters she wrote to Pearl. The dynamic between the two sisters was something I enjoyed about Shanghai Girls and this was missing in Dreams of Joy. But these are minor criticisms compared to how much I enjoyed reading the book - in the final chapters I was reading as fast as I could as I was desperate to see what would happen to Joy and Pearl. Highly recommended.
Verdict: Excellent sequel to Shanghai Girls that illuminates Chinese suffering during the Great Leap Forward.
Source: Library (reservation)
First Published: 2011
Score: 5 out of 5
I enjoyed this review. I haven't read either but I like good historical fiction and mother-daughter fics, so I'll add them to my to-read list. The plot also reminds me of a friend who, when he was young, was idealistic and naive and wound up supporting some dubious causes. Thankfully he never got mired in them or trapped in another country, and they weren't as destructive as Mao's policies, but he was definitely wearing rose-colored glasses and could see little wrong.
ReplyDeleteGreat review. I also like a good historical fiction as much as the next guy especially if I learn something from it.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.ManOfLaBook.com
HKatz, you friend's experience does sound similar to Joy's in the novel. I think we have all been in that situation to extent, but thankfully not in Communist China!
ReplyDeleteMan of la Book, hope you enjoy it.
I loved Snowflower and The Secret Fan, but I very much disliked Shanghai Girls. I'm glad to hear that this sequel met your expectations, but if it follows Shanghai Girls, I don't thing it's for me.
ReplyDeleteBellezza, why didn't you like Shanghai Girls? I preferred it to Snow Flower and the Secret Fan.
ReplyDeleteI also loved Snowflower and the Secret Fan and Peony in Love so much better than Shanghai Girls. I liked the beginning of Shanghai Girls, but the book fell flat for me once they came to the United States.
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed Shanghai Girls and I thought this one was even better. I missed May's character too, though, and it would have been nice if there had been a few chapters written from her perspective.
ReplyDeleteBeachreader, that's the part of Shanghai Girls I liked, I liked how See explored the prejudice they faced, especially at Angel Island.
ReplyDeleteShereadsnovels, I agree that a few chapters written from May's perspective would have been a welcome addition.
What a pretty cover. I haven't read Shanghai Girls but maybe it should go on my to buy once my tbr has fallen list ;)
ReplyDeleteI read Snow Flower & The Secret Fan last year and really enjoyed it so I'd love to read more by Lisa See. Thanks for your insightful review, I think this may be the next one by her that I pick up! The title is lovely, too.
ReplyDeleteIm a new follower :)
I enjoyed Dreams of Joy, too although I think Shanghai Girls was my favorite of the two. Like you, I missed May in Dreams of Joy. I was shocked by the conditions in China's country-side. It's so sad what the peasants experienced. And some as pects of China under Mao were strictly enforced while others were ignored...I wondered a bit how true to life this was but didn't feel I had to stretch my imagination to believe some of the things that happened. I think Lisa See does an enormous amount of research before she writes. Then again, this is fiction so maybe I shouldn't believe everything I read about the situation in China! I had hoped to get to know Joy's father a little more and through his own thoughts and words. Still I liked Dreams of Joy very much!
ReplyDeleteThank you for a wonderful review, I really enjoyed it!
Great review! I think I've enjoyed (and learned something) from every book of Lisa See's that I've read. It's hard to say which of her books I've liked the best because all the stories have been really powerful but some have also had some really difficult scenes to read. (I won't give any spoilers but I could venture a guess at a passage that may have made Shanghai Girls a distasteful book to some.)
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed this book a lot also. i also like her two historical novels set in the 19th century. She really brings to life the horror of foot binding
ReplyDeleteAwesome. I read Shanghai Girls and have been waiting for my library hold for Dreams of Joy to come in. It's great to know that the sequel doesn't disappoint!
ReplyDelete